Share this article

These tasty pots are a winner with Slimming World members – and we love finding new and exciting flavour combinations. This peanut butter and jam version makes the most of peanut butter’s new status as a Healthy Extra healthy fats choice – and it’s so simple to make. Here’s how… 

Slimming World's Ultimate Fakeaways cookbook - free recipe book worth £4.95/€7.95 - terms and conditions apply - click here to find out more.

Peanut butter and jam overnight cheesecake video

Peanut butter and jam overnight cheesecake recipe 

serves 1 
ready in 10 mins (plus overnight chilling) 


7½ Swips (deduct 6 Swips if you’re having the wheat biscuits as your Healthy Extra fibre choice and deduct 1½ Swips if you’re having the peanut butter as half a Healthy Extra healthy fats choice) 

What you need: 

2 wheat biscuits 
2 tbsp fat-free natural Greek yogurt 

To top: 
sliced banana  
fresh raspberries 
150g fat-free natural Greek yogurt 
12g sugar-free 100% nut peanut butter  
1 level tsp reduced-sugar strawberry jam 

What you do:  

1. Put the wheat biscuits in a bowl and crush them with your hands or a fork. Add the 2 tbsp yogurt and mix together.   

2. Spoon the mixture into the base of a dessert glass and press it down firmly.   

3. Top with the sliced banana and raspberries. 

4. Spoon the yogurt over and spread it out evenly. 

5. Dollop the peanut butter and strawberry jam on top. Cover and chill overnight. 

More overnight cheesecake recipes 

Weetabix cheesecake Biscoff

We’ve tried and tested Biscoff, berry, choc-strawberry and more! 

Slimming World's Ultimate Fakeaways cookbook - free recipe book worth £4.95/€7.95 - from 15th February to 7th March 2026 - terms and conditions apply - click here to find out more.

Share this article